Planning for and responding to pandemic influenza emergencies: it’s time to listen to, prioritize and privilege Aboriginal perspectives
Kristy Crooks,a,d Peter D Massey,a,b Kylie Taylor,c Adrian Miller,e Sandra Campbellf and Ross Andrewsd,g
a Hunter New England Local Health District, Population Health, Wallsend, New South Wales, Australia.
b College of Medicine and Dentistry, James Cook University, Cairns, Queensland, Australia.
c Hunter New England Local Health District, Population Health, Tamworth, New South Wales, Australia.
d Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Casuarina, Darwin, Northern Territory, Australia.
e Office of Indigenous Engagement, Central Queensland University, Townsville, Queensland, Australia.
f Indigenous Health, Research Division, Central Queensland University, Cairns, Queensland, Australia.
g National Centre for Epidemiology & Population Health, Australian National University, Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia.
Correspondence to Kristy Crooks (email:firstname.lastname@example.org).
To cite this article:
Crooks K, Massey PD, Taylor K, Miller A, Campbell S, Andrews R, et al. Planning for and responding to pandemic influenza emergencies: it’s time to listen to, prioritize and privilege Aboriginal perspectives. Western Pac Surveill Response J. 2018 Nov;9(5). doi:10.5365/wpsar.2018.9.5.005
Australia’s Indigenous peoples account for 3% of the country’s population yet continue to experience disproportionately higher rates of mortality and hospitalization for many infectious diseases.1 The 2009 influenza pandemic had an inequitable impact on Indigenous peoples in Australia,2 New Zealand,3 the Americas and the Pacific.4 Genuine and tangible actions that include Indigenous peoples in the planning and response for pandemic influenza is overdue. This paper will identify some of the strategies to incorporate the perspectives of Australia’s Indigenous peoples (hereafter Aboriginal) in planning and responding to infectious disease emergencies.
Historically, infectious diseases have had a major impact on Indigenous peoples internationally. In North America, European contact and ensuing economic developments changed the nature of infectious disease ecology and exacerbated the frequency and severity of the problem for this population.5 The European invasion of Australia brought new diseases such as varicella, smallpox, influenza and measles to which Aboriginal people had little or no immunity.6 The influenza pandemic of 1918–1919 had a devastating impact on the Aboriginal population;7 however, the full impact is unlikely to be known because many Aboriginal deaths went unrecorded.6 In the 2009 Australian influenza pandemic, the rate ratio comparing Aboriginal people in New South Wales with non-Aboriginal people was 4.2 for hospital admissions, 3.9 for intensive care unit admissions and 5.6 for deaths.8
The health science field, dominated by scientific quantitative methods often fails to recognize Aboriginal perspectives9 as Aboriginal ways of knowing and being are fundamentally different and culturally specific. These differences need to be acknowledged and understood by public health professionals and policy-makers and incorporated into health practice and policy. The omission of Aboriginal people from Australia’s pre-2009 pandemic plan10 is an example of how Aboriginal people have been excluded from the planning and response to infectious disease emergencies. While the current Australian pandemic plan highlights the need for equity and two-way communication with Aboriginal people, there are no recommendations on how to achieve this, and, therefore, the plan inadequately addresses the needs of Aboriginal communities.11
Aboriginal people continue to be the subject of health service delivery and policy without the opportunity to be part of the decision-making about their health.12 Given the historical factors and complexities of contemporary Aboriginal health, a one-size-fits-all approach to pandemic influenza is unlikely to work.13–15 Measures to reduce the risk of public health emergencies in Aboriginal communities need to be developed with and led by communities to maximize their acceptance, impact and effect. There must be a clear process of engagement and two-way respectful and meaningful communication with Aboriginal communities to identify culturally appropriate and effective public health control strategies.13
To ensure cultural appropriateness in pandemic influenza planning and response, management plans and control strategies must appropriately reflect and prioritize the social realities of Aboriginal communities. Families are an intrinsic element in Aboriginal culture; therefore, emphasis on the value of kinship, family structures and social connectedness with a family-centred approach should be adopted.13 Additionally, pandemic influenza control strategies often include household contacts, but this may or may not encapsulate the risk for Aboriginal families where shared lives and communities are different from mainstream Australia. These differences must be incorporated into pandemic influenza planning so that Aboriginal people are no longer disproportionately affected.
Participatory approaches with Aboriginal communities are becoming a more culturally appropriate and acceptable method for strengthening engagement and building community empowerment.16 Collaborative engagement processes using qualitative approaches could provide insight into the diverse community perspectives,16,17 and identify barriers to implementation of disease control strategies.18 Plans and control strategies need to:
- be developed early with Aboriginal organizations and key stakeholders;
- be flexible to meet local priorities;
- include how to reduce risk in families and at large community events;
- ensure targeted communication strategies are co-developed;
- have flexible models of health care to access vaccinations and other medical interventions, and
- include a stakeholder engagement plan
Including these aspects in pandemic planning are integral to enable Aboriginal people to achieve the level of risk of influenza as the general population and look to a future where Aboriginal people can thrive.
In this period, before the next influenza pandemic, it is the time to listen, prioritize and privilege Indigenous voices internationally. To privilege Aboriginal voices means more than just an equity approach, it is about removing paternalistic approaches to health care and moving beyond listening to and consulting with Aboriginal people about health issues. It is about creating a space where Aboriginal people are at the centre, guiding decision-making processes within a culturally appropriate governance structure that is built on the principles of collaboration, power-sharing, transparent communication, mutual accountability and shared responsibility. Infectious disease emergency plans developed without respectful and meaningful engagement is identified as a barrier to acceptance and implementation.13 Specific localized plans for Aboriginal communities are needed13 that are culturally centred, reflect the diverse socio-cultural practices and that can be reassessed and updated in collaboration with public health emergency leaders to meet the changing needs of the community.16 Infectious disease emergency planners must, with Aboriginal peoples, develop a robust understanding of the issues, be culturally safe, appropriate, inclusive and responsive in the development of disease control strategies. This can happen only if public health approaches are developed in partnership with Aboriginal people, not for them. Aboriginal people need to be engaged in the dialogue, leading the way in the construction of knowledge that is supportive of self-determination. Privileging Aboriginal voices will enable culturally informed strategies and may reduce inequity and the risk of pandemic influenza.
Australia’s heath 2016. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2016 (https://www.aihw.gov.au/getmedia/9844cefb-7745-4dd8-9ee2-f4d1c3d6a727/19787-AH16.pdf.aspx).
Flint SM, Davis JS, Su JY, Oliver-Landry EP, Rogers BA, Goldstein A, et al. Disproportionate impact of pandemic (H1N1) 2009 influenza on Indigenous people in the Top End of Australia’s Northern Territory. Med J Aust. 2010 May 17;192(10):617–22.
Bandaranayake D, Bissielo A, Huang S, Wood T. Seroprevalence of the 2009 influenza A (H1N1) pandemic in New Zealand. Wellington: Ministry of Health; 2010 (https://www.health.govt.nz/system/files/documents/publications/seroprevalence-flu-2009.pdf).
La Ruche G, Tarantola A, Barboza P, Vaillant L, Gueguen J, Gastellu-Etchegorry M; epidemic intelligence team at InVS. The 2009 pandemic H1N1 influenza and Indigenous populations of the Americas and the Pacific. Euro Surveill. 2009 Oct 22;14(42):19366.
Herring DA, Sattenspiel L. Social contexts, syndemics, and infectious disease in northern Aboriginal populations. Am J Hum Biol. 2007 Mar-Apr;19(2):190–202.
Dowling P. “A great deal of sickness”: Introduced diseases among the Aboriginal people of colonial Southeast Australia. PhD thesis. Canberra: Australian National University; 2011 (https://openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au/handle/1885/7529).
Curson P, McCracken K. An Australian perspective of the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic. N S W Public Health Bull. 2006 Jul-Aug;17(7-8):103–7.
Rudge S, Massey PD. Responding to pandemic (H1N1) 2009 influenza in Aboriginal communities in NSW through collaboration between NSW Health and the Aboriginal community-controlled health sector. N S W Public Health Bull. 2010 Jan-Feb;21(1-2):26-9.
Smith LT. Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous peoples. London: Zed Books Ltd.; 2013.
Miller A, Durrheim AD; Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Community Influenza Study Group. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities forgotten in new Australian National Action Plan for Human Influenza Pandemic: “Ask us, listen to us, share with us”. Med J Aust. 2010 Sep 20;193(6):316–7.
Australian Health Management Plan for Pandemic Influenza. Canberra: Department of Health; 2014 (http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/content/ohp-ahmppi.htm).
Sherwood J. Colonisation - it’s bad for your health: the context of Aboriginal health. Contemp Nurse. 2013 Dec;46(1):28–40.
Massey PD, Miller A, Saggers S, Durrheim DN, Speare R, Taylor K, et al. Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and the development of pandemic influenza containment strategies: community voices and community control. Health Policy. 2011 Dec;103(2-3):184–90.
Groom AV, Jim C, Laroque M, Mason C, McLaughlin J, Neel L, et al. Pandemic influenza preparedness and vulnerable populations in tribal communities. Am J Public Health. 2009 Oct;99(S2) Suppl 2:S271–8.
Gray L, MacDonald C, Mackie B, Paton D, Johnston D, Baker MG. Community responses to communication campaigns for influenza A (H1N1): a focus group study. BMC Public Health. 2012 03 19;12(1):205.
Miller A, Massey PD, Judd J, Kelly J, Durrheim DN, Clough AR, et al. Using a participatory action research framework to listen to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in Australia about pandemic influenza. Rural Remote Health. 2015 Jul-Sep;15(3):2923.
Charania NA, Tsuji LJ. A community-based participatory approach and engagement process creates culturally appropriate and community informed pandemic plans after the 2009 H1N1 influenza pandemic: remote and isolated First Nations communities of sub-arctic Ontario, Canada. BMC Public Health. 2012 04 3;12(1):268.
Uscher-Pines L, Duggan PS, Garoon JP, Karron RA, Faden RR. Social justice and disadvantaged groups. Hastings Cent Rep. 2007 Jul-Aug;37(4):32–9.