a Morobe Provincial Hospital, Lae, Papua New Guinea.
b World Health Organization, Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea.
c Bulolo District Health Services, Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea.
d Papua New Guinea Institute of Medical Research, Goroka, Papua New Guinea.
e Angua Hospital, Lae, Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea.
f School of Applied and Biomedical Services, Federation University, Churchill, Victoria, Australia.
Correspondence to Paul F Horwood (e-mail: paul.horwood@hotmail.com).
To cite this article:
Benny E et al. A large outbreak of shigellosis commencing in an internally displaced population, Papua New Guinea, 2013. Western Pacific Surveillance and Response Journal, 2014, 5(3). doi:10.5365/wpsar.2014.5.2.003
Objective: The objective of this study was to investigate a large outbreak of shigellosis in Papua New Guinea that began in a camp for internally displaced persons before spreading throughout the general community.
Methods: Outbreak mitigation strategies were implemented in the affected area to curtail the spread of the disease. Data were collected from the surveillance system and analysed by time, place and person. Rectal swab samples were tested by standard culture methods and real-time polymerase chain reaction to determine the etiology of the outbreak.
Results: Laboratory analysis at two independent institutions established that the outbreak was caused by Shigella sp., with one strain further characterized as Shigella flexneri serotype 2. Approximately 1200 suspected cases of shigellosis were reported in a two-month period from two townships in Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea. The outbreak resulted in at least five deaths, all in young children.
Discussion: This outbreak of shigellosis highlights the threat of enteric diseases to vulnerable populations such as internally displaced persons in Papua New Guinea, as has been observed in other global settings.
Shigellosis (bacillary dysentery) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality, particularly in developing countries. The number of Shigella infections throughout the world annually has been estimated at more than 160 million cases, with more than 1 million deaths. The majority of these cases (> 60%) and deaths (> 70%) occur in children younger than five years.1 The disease is endemic in most developing countries and caused by four species of Shigella, which are classified based on biochemical and serological differences: Shigella dysenteriae, S. flexneri, S. boydii and S. sonnei. Shigellosis is typically spread through the faecal–oral route by person-to-person contact or through contaminated food or water. It is a known risk among refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs).2 The infectious dose of Shigella can be as low as 10 organisms,3 thus facilitating the rapid spread of the organism during outbreaks. The symptoms of shigellosis include fever, watery diarrhoea, abdominal cramps and bloody stools with mucus.
In this study we report on the epidemiological and laboratory findings of a large outbreak of shigellosis which commenced in a settlement camp for IDPs before spreading throughout the general community in Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea. An outbreak investigation was initiated following reports of numerous cases of gastrointestinal disease in a settlement camp in Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea in September 2013. The settlement camp was established following tribal fighting between two neighbouring groups, the Watut and Bupu Garaina people; the Bupu Garaina people were internally displaced following the conflict.
The outbreak was first reported in late September 2013 from a health centre close to the settlement camp near the township of Bulolo, Morobe Province. Over the next two weeks, more than 300 cases of diarrhoea and dysentery were recorded at the health centre in close proximity to the camp. Over the subsequent weeks, the outbreak spread to the township of Bulolo and then to the nearby township of Wau, which is located approximately 50 km away. The case definition for this outbreak was clinic attendees with acute watery and loose stools (with or without mucus and blood) and with or without fever. Detailed line lists were compiled from representative patients to include age, sex, onset date, presentation date, residence, clinical symptoms, outcome and laboratory results. Data were analysed in Microsoft Excel 2010.
Following the initial reports of the outbreak, local and provincial health teams were mobilized and outbreak mitigation strategies were implemented:
Rectal swabs were collected and stored in Cary-Blair medium and sent to the Angau Memorial Hospital (Lae, Morobe Province) and the Papua New Guinea Institute of Medical Research (Goroka, Eastern Highlands Province) for bacterial culture analysis using standard methods as outlined by the World Health Organization. Samples were also tested for Shigella spp. using a previously published real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay.4
The public health activities and laboratory testing outlined in this study were organized by the Ministry of Health and Morobe Provincial Health Authority as part of routine outbreak investigation procedures, and as such have a standing authorisation from the National Ethics Committee. All samples were anonymised for the purpose of this study.
An increase in cases of dysentery and diarrhoea was first recorded at the Bulolo Health Centre in the last week of September 2013 (Figure 1). By the end of the first week of October, over 20 cases of dysentery/diarrhoea were being reported at the clinic per day. In the second week of October cases began presenting at the Wau Health Centre. Dysentery/diarrhoea cases continued to be reported from both Bulolo and Wau until the first week of November. Overall, approximately 1200 cases of diarrhoea and dysentery were reported from the Bulolo/Wau area. The majority of cases were recorded at the Bulolo Health Centre (approximately 900), with the remaining cases recorded at the Wau Health Centre (approximately 300). A detailed line list from randomly selected patients was compiled for 510 cases from the outbreak (Bulolo–368; Wau–142) and the remaining cases were reported as aggregated data.
Note: The data are based on 358 patients for whom date of onset was recorded.
The outbreak resulted in five deaths (three in Bulolo and two in Wau), with a case fatality proportion of approximately 0.4%. All of the deaths occurred in children under five years of age, and pre-existing morbidities and late presentation to health clinics were believed to be important factors in all of the deaths. There were unconfirmed reports of additional deaths that were not recorded due to the remoteness of the outbreak region.
Among the cases for whom age was recorded (n = 496), the majority were in children: over 70% of age-reported cases were in children less than 15 years of age with a large proportion less than five years of age. Children less than five years old accounted for 58.3% (n = 289) of cases; children five to 14 years: 13.1% (n = 65); people aged 15–50 years: 25.0% (n = 124); and older adults more than 50 years: 3.6% (n = 18). Males were more commonly recorded with dysentery/diarrhoea symptoms during the outbreak, constituting 54.3% of cases. However, there was no statistical difference in male–female cases.
Shigella sp. was isolated from four out of six stool samples analysed at the Angau Memorial Hospital laboratory. Shigella sp. was also isolated from one out of 11 stool samples analysed at the Papua New Guinea Institute of Medical Research. This isolate was subsequently serotyped as S. flexneri serotype 2 using Shigella antisera (Denka Seiken Co. Ltd, Tokyo, Japan). In addition, three of the 11 samples tested positive for Shigella sp. using real-time PCR. The sample from which the S. flexneri strain was isolated was one of the positive samples. The S. flexneri isolate was archived and will be used for genomic analysis to further characterize the outbreak strain.
With the assistance of the police and town council, the communities heeded the ban on sales of ice blocks and cooked food. The ORS treatment points were maintained until no more cases were reported. Toilets were built for the care centres, and several IDPs were voluntarily repatriated to their home villages. An awareness task force led by the officer-in-charge of the Bulolo Health Centre covered all of the hamlets and sections of the towns with prevention messages on the Five Fs (Food, Fingers, Fluid, Faeces, Flies). Shops and fast food outlets not conforming to the standards and instructions issued by environmental health officers were given notice and followed up until they complied.
In this paper we report on a large outbreak of shigellosis that commenced in a settlement camp for IDPs before spreading to the surrounding community and another township in the same area. The outbreak resulted in approximately 1200 cases of suspected shigellosis, which is one of the largest outbreaks reported in the literature.
This outbreak highlights the threat of shigellosis to vulnerable populations. At particular risk are displaced persons, refugees and people in institutional settings. However, as the spread of this outbreak to the broader community illustrates, much of the population-at-large is at risk of shigellosis. Papua New Guinea has one of the lowest rates of access to safe water and sanitation in the Western Pacific Region.5,6 In this instance, the outbreak originated in a settlement camp for displaced persons; however, the rapid spread of the disease throughout the general community is an indication that improvements are needed in the delivery of basic services. The recent country-wide outbreak of cholera is further evidence of the impact that enteric diseases can have on regions where there is inadequate access to safe water and sanitation.7 Improvements in safe water and sanitation, though often challenging to implement and maintain in remote, resource-poor settings, need to be prioritized.8
Shigella has been established as an important cause of disease in Papua New Guinea. In a recent study in the highlands of the country, Shigella was isolated from 22% of patients (adults and children) presenting to an urban clinic or hospital outpatients with diarrhoea/dysentery; with S. flexneri the most common species detected.9 Similarly, a molecular-based study detected Shigella as the most common pathogen in children (less than five years old) hospitalized with acute watery diarrhoea in the same setting.10 An outbreak of shigellosis, attributed to S. flexneri serotype 3, was reported in a remote region of Papua New Guinea in 2009, complicated by a concurrent outbreak of H3N2 influenza.11 These findings are of great importance given the lack of a vaccine to prevent infection with Shigella and the increasing antibiotic resistance of Shigella globally, including Papua New Guinea.9,12
In this study, the low isolation and detection rates of Shigella from outbreak samples were probably due to the extended time between sample collection and laboratory testing (more than a week). The logistical issues of transporting clinical material in Papua New Guinea have been noted previously during recent outbreaks of cholera,13 shigellosis11 and chikungunya.14 Incomplete road networks and the paucity of diagnostic laboratories commonly hamper disease outbreak investigations. However, the isolation of Shigella from independent sampling and testing from two laboratories confirm that Shigella sp. was the etiological agent of the outbreak. During the shigellosis outbreak, fragile health care systems and poorly equipped clinics were further stretched by the increase in cases. Although this resulted in suboptimal completion of line lists and may affect the representativeness of the data, we are confident that the results presented in this paper are an accurate description of the shigellosis outbreak in this region. Further studies to fully understand the epidemiology of shigellosis are required in Papua New Guinea with the hope that control strategies can be developed.
None declared.
None.
The authors thank the staff from the Bulolo and Wau Health Centres and the general community from the two townships for their assistance with our investigations. Field investigations and outbreak mitigation measures were conducted with support from the Government of Papua New Guinea, the Morobe Provincial Health Authority and the World Health Organization. Laboratory investigations at the Papua New Guinea Institute of Medical Research were supported by the Internal Competitive Research Award Scheme from the Government of Papua New Guinea.
